From: Scars of early non-employment for low educated youth: evidence and policy lessons from Belgium
Second stage | ||||||
Outcomes: a | Salaried empl. | Self-empl. | Overall empl. | |||
OLS | 2SLS | OLS | 2SLS | OLS | 2SLS | |
Clustered standard errors: | g∗p | g∗p | g∗p | g∗p | g∗p | g∗p |
(1) | (2) | (3) | (4) | (5) | (6) | |
Early non-empl. | –0.00169*** | –0.00256 | 0.00054 | 0.00248 | –0.00115*** | –0.00008 |
(0.00041) | (0.00290) | (0.00041) | (0.00258) | (0.00025) | (0.00151) | |
UR_pe6 | 0.00481 | 0.00404 | 0.01081 | 0.01253 | 0.01562 | 0.01657* |
(0.02385) | (0.02209) | (0.01947) | (0.01765) | (0.01020) | (0.00999) | |
lin_grad_year | –0.00253 | –0.00009 | –0.01367 | –0.01911 | –0.01621 | –0.01920 |
(0.03120) | (0.03028) | (0.02544) | (0.02343) | (0.01397) | (0.01340) | |
lin_grad_year |trend>3 | 0.02993 | 0.02680 | 0.00338 | 0.01032 | 0.03331* | 0.03712** |
(0.04020) | (0.04043) | (0.03029) | (0.02903) | (0.01832) | (0.01813) | |
lin_grad_year |trend>6 | –0.01720 | –0.01695 | 0.01884 | 0.01829 | 0.00164 | 0.00134 |
(0.02568) | (0.02477) | (0.02503) | (0.02252) | (0.01457) | (0.01375) | |
d_province2 | –0.22288** | –0.22144** | 0.17666* | 0.17347** | –0.04621 | –0.04797 |
(0.09844) | (0.09548) | (0.09049) | (0.08719) | (0.04174) | (0.03996) | |
d_province3 | –0.17150*** | –0.18038*** | 0.13845** | 0.15820** | –0.03304 | –0.02218 |
(0.06193) | (0.06407) | (0.06588) | (0.06577) | (0.03720) | (0.04285) | |
d_province4 | –0.11409** | –0.11292** | 0.10736** | 0.10477** | –0.00673 | –0.00816 |
(0.04892) | (0.04910) | (0.04459) | (0.04794) | (0.02450) | (0.02611) | |
d_province5 | 0.04132 | 0.04158 | –0.06171 | –0.06229 | –0.02039 | –0.02071 |
(0.06183) | (0.06032) | (0.04557) | (0.04483) | (0.03418) | (0.03449) | |
lin_calend_year_prov2 | 0.01976 | 0.01966 | –0.01544 | –0.01521 | 0.00432 | 0.00445 |
(0.01597) | (0.01524) | (0.01253) | (0.01214) | (0.00565) | (0.00651) | |
lin_calend_year_prov3 | –0.00496 | –0.00387 | 0.00501 | 0.00259 | 0.00005 | –0.00128 |
(0.01207) | (0.01140) | (0.01565) | (0.01376) | (0.00716) | (0.00690) | |
lin_calend_year_prov4 | 0.01299 | 0.01231 | –0.01369 | –0.01217 | –0.00070 | 0.00014 |
(0.01118) | (0.01157) | (0.00964) | (0.01055) | (0.00642) | (0.00679) | |
lin_calend_year_prov5 | –0.00608 | –0.00602 | 0.01656 | 0.01642* | 0.01048** | 0.01041** |
(0.01074) | (0.01027) | (0.01012) | (0.00967) | (0.00471) | (0.00491) | |
avg_UR_pe3-6 | –0.08309** | –0.08489** | 0.03333 | 0.03733 | –0.04976* | –0.04756* |
(0.04062) | (0.04005) | (0.03418) | (0.03230) | (0.02622) | (0.02516) | |
Min_UR_pe0-6 | –0.01193 | –0.01089 | 0.00452 | 0.00222 | –0.00741 | –0.00867 |
(0.06247) | (0.05970) | (0.05849) | (0.05672) | (0.02769) | (0.02854) | |
Birth cohort76 | 0.00488 | –0.00741 | 0.01471 | 0.04204 | 0.01959 | 0.03462 |
(0.04397) | (0.06402) | (0.03588) | (0.05434) | (0.02535) | (0.03517) | |
Birth cohort78 | 0.02309 | 0.01743 | –0.00086 | 0.01173 | 0.02223 | 0.02916 |
(0.03666) | (0.04407) | (0.03059) | (0.03645) | (0.01745) | (0.02152) | |
live in single-parent | –0.00309 | 0.00220 | –0.03561 | –0.04736 | –0.03870 | –0.04516 |
(0.05525) | (0.05471) | (0.05233) | (0.05472) | (0.03217) | (0.03371) | |
Not live with parents | 0.02521 | 0.02631 | –0.01502 | –0.01748 | 0.01019 | 0.00883 |
(0.02900) | (0.02995) | (0.02753) | (0.03031) | (0.01581) | (0.01592) | |
HH members aged 0–11 | –0.00246 | –0.00124 | 0.00596 | 0.00325 | 0.00350 | 0.00201 |
(0.01217) | (0.01251) | (0.01277) | (0.01265) | (0.00574) | (0.00627) | |
HH members aged 12–17 | 0.02291* | 0.02265* | –0.01252 | –0.01196 | 0.01039 | 0.01070 |
(0.01185) | (0.01173) | (0.01041) | (0.01069) | (0.00709) | (0.00683) | |
HH members aged 18–29 | 0.00009 | 0.00240 | 0.00374 | –0.00139 | 0.00384 | 0.00101 |
(0.01152) | (0.01355) | (0.01034) | (0.01150) | (0.00604) | (0.00688) | |
HH members aged 30–64 | –0.01697 | –0.01752 | –0.02276 | –0.02152 | –0.03972 | –0.03904 |
(0.05212) | (0.05087) | (0.04874) | (0.04896) | (0.02847) | (0.02961) | |
HH members aged 65+ | –0.02001 | –0.01884 | 0.00730 | 0.00469 | –0.01271 | –0.01414 |
(0.04165) | (0.04136) | (0.03573) | (0.03540) | (0.02182) | (0.02205) | |
Father education | –0.00132 | –0.00099 | 0.00045 | –0.00030 | –0.00087 | –0.00128 |
(0.00198) | (0.00226) | (0.00202) | (0.00213) | (0.00160) | (0.00170) | |
Mother education | –0.00971*** | –0.00904** | 0.00937*** | 0.00787** | –0.00034 | –0.00116 |
(0.00341) | (0.00417) | (0.00294) | (0.00327) | (0.00181) | (0.00210) | |
Years of delay in sec.edu | 0.00440 | 0.00919 | –0.02391** | –0.03456* | –0.01952*** | –0.02537* |
(0.01275) | (0.02067) | (0.01070) | (0.01764) | (0.00702) | (0.01381) | |
Technical edu | 0.01038 | –0.00031 | 0.02957 | 0.05333 | 0.03995*** | 0.05301** |
(0.03694) | (0.04459) | (0.03180) | (0.04181) | (0.01452) | (0.02678) | |
Vocational edu | 0.00818 | –0.00144 | 0.03776 | 0.05914 | 0.04594*** | 0.05770** |
(0.03164) | (0.04096) | (0.02700) | (0.04065) | (0.01546) | (0.02569) | |
Apprenticeship/PT edu | –0.06240 | –0.07366 | 0.08533* | 0.11033** | 0.02292 | 0.03667 |
(0.05336) | (0.06364) | (0.04311) | (0.05434) | (0.02842) | (0.03967) | |
Constant | 1.41749*** | 1.45409*** | –0.15519 | –0.23651 | 1.26230*** | 1.21757*** |
(0.35242) | (0.37325) | (0.32471) | (0.34533) | (0.20910) | (0.22952) | |
Observations | 1,902 | 1,902 | 1,902 | 1,902 | 1,902 | 1,902 |
R-squared | 0.04170 | 0.03730 | 0.03098 | 0.00332 | 0.05818 | 0.03540 |
Exogeneity test P-val b | 0.767 | 0.438 | 0.467 |